A Formal Counter-Response to Draft2Digital: The Difference Between Low Sales, Low-Content Publishing, and Original Literary Work
By Leonardo Mora
Introduction: A Decision That Deserves Greater Scrutiny
To the Draft2Digital Management and Content Review Team,
I am writing in response to your decision to permanently close my publishing account, remove my published titles from distribution, and characterize my work as low-content or mass-produced material that does not meet your standards.
I understand that Draft2Digital has the right to establish publishing guidelines, maintain relationships with distribution partners, and reject material that does not comply with its policies. No serious author disputes the importance of originality, editorial quality, appropriate formatting, and a positive reading experience.
However, the existence of publishing standards does not eliminate the need for consistency, transparency, proportionality, and a meaningful distinction between different circumstances.
Your notification combines several separate concepts: low sales volume, low-content publishing, mass-produced material, automated creation, and insufficient literary value. These concepts are not interchangeable. A fair evaluation should distinguish them and explain which specific characteristics of my books supposedly justify the decision.
My principal objection is straightforward: an author's commercial performance is not proof of the quality, originality, or substantive depth of that author's work. Likewise, publishing multiple books does not automatically establish that those books are mass-produced or deficient.
I therefore request a reconsideration of the decision based on identifiable evidence about the actual manuscripts, rather than a broad classification that does not identify the specific deficiencies in the affected titles.
1. Low Sales Volume Is Not a Content Defect
One of the most important distinctions in publishing is the difference between the quality of a book and the number of copies it sells.
An author can write a substantial, carefully researched, original, and intellectually meaningful book that sells only a handful of copies. Another author can sell thousands of copies of a relatively simple work because the author already has an established audience, an effective marketing operation, strong retailer visibility, or a substantial advertising budget.
Commercial performance is influenced by numerous factors, including:
The size and purchasing behavior of the author's existing audience.
The visibility of a book in search results and retailer recommendations.
Competition from established authors and publishers.
The effectiveness of promotional campaigns.
The availability of reviews and reader recommendations.
Pricing, cover design, metadata, and discoverability.
The author's financial ability to sustain advertising.
The timing of publication and the relevance of the subject to potential readers.
An author cannot independently control all these variables.
Publishing a book makes it available to potential readers; it does not guarantee that those readers will discover it. Distribution is not the same as promotion, and availability is not the same as demand.
If a book sells poorly, that outcome may reflect weak marketing, limited reach, an audience that has not yet discovered the work, or a subject that appeals to a relatively small readership. It does not, by itself, establish that the book contains insufficient material or lacks originality.
A book that has not found its audience is not necessarily a book without value.
This distinction is particularly important for independent authors, who often lack the marketing resources, publicity teams, and established distribution relationships enjoyed by major publishing operations.
A publisher may have the resources to finance advertising campaigns, hire publicists, arrange interviews, and promote titles across multiple channels. An independent author may have to rely on organic discovery and gradually develop an audience.
It would therefore be unreasonable to treat limited commercial visibility as conclusive evidence of literary inadequacy.
2. An Author Cannot Manufacture Sales Volume Without Resources
If the underlying concern is that an author's books have not achieved sufficient commercial traction, the practical question becomes: what can an author reasonably do to increase sales?
The answer includes improving book descriptions, selecting appropriate categories, refining covers, developing an audience, requesting legitimate reviews, and promoting work through available channels.
These activities can help. None guarantees a particular sales volume.
More aggressive promotional strategies can require substantial financial investment. Paid advertising, professional publicity, influencer campaigns, and sustained promotional activity may consume significant resources before producing measurable returns. Even a large advertising expenditure does not guarantee profitability.
For an independent author, the choice to invest in advertising also involves financial risk. Spending heavily to satisfy an assumed expectation of sales could result in losses rather than sustainable growth.
Furthermore, advertising cannot ethically or reliably substitute for genuine reader interest. It can introduce a book to potential buyers, but it cannot guarantee that they will purchase it, finish reading it, recommend it, or leave a positive review.
Consequently, if Draft2Digital's actual concern is low sales volume, the author should not be expected to solve that problem through an unlimited advertising budget.
Nor should the absence of such a budget be interpreted as evidence that the author's books were produced through a content farm, contain little substance, or were generated automatically.
Those are different allegations requiring different evidence.
The appropriate question is not simply whether a title has sold enough copies. It is whether the manuscript meets the applicable content standards.
If sales performance played any role in this decision, I request that Draft2Digital clarify that role and identify the policy under which sales volume, if relevant, became a basis for account termination.
3. Multiple Publications Do Not Automatically Constitute Mass Production
Another issue requiring clarification is the apparent relationship between the number of publications associated with an author and the conclusion that those publications are mass-produced.
Authors work at different speeds. Some publish one book every several years. Others publish frequently because they write shorter works, maintain a disciplined writing schedule, explore multiple subjects, or have accumulated manuscripts over an extended period.
Productivity alone does not establish a lack of originality.
A person who writes extensively about philosophy, human behavior, technology, education, business, or personal development may produce multiple works because those subjects contain numerous questions worth exploring. A common author, publisher, or philosophical perspective does not make every publication a duplicate.
The relevant issue is whether the books contain distinct substantive contributions.
Do they present different arguments? Do they develop separate concepts? Do they examine different questions? Do they provide original analysis, examples, frameworks, or interpretations? Do they offer readers meaningful material beyond what appears in the other titles?
Those questions can be evaluated through manuscript review.
By contrast, a broad judgment based on publication frequency risks confusing legitimate productivity with automated content production.
If Draft2Digital believes that my titles contain duplicated passages or differ only through minor changes, I request the identification of the specific titles, passages, and similarities that support that conclusion.
If the concern is that the books were generated through automated means, I request clarification of the evidence supporting that characterization.
If the concern is insufficient substantive content, I request an explanation of which manuscripts allegedly fail to meet the applicable standard and why.
These are reasonable requests for specificity. They do not require Draft2Digital to accept every manuscript, but they would allow the decision to be understood and meaningfully challenged.
4. Low-Content Books and Substantive Nonfiction Are Different Categories
Draft2Digital's published guidance identifies examples of low-content books such as journals, notebooks, diaries, planners, and similar works centered on content supplied by the end user. Its content guidelines also address mass-produced material, insufficient quality, and entirely AI-generated content that has not undergone extensive human editing.
Those categories should not be collapsed into one broad judgment.
A journal with hundreds of blank pages is fundamentally different from a nonfiction book containing chapters, arguments, explanations, and conclusions. A planner is different from an essay collection. A book containing original analysis is different from a product consisting primarily of repeated templates.
The distinction should be made by examining what the reader actually receives.
A nonfiction work should be assessed according to its substantive content, organization, originality, and usefulness—not simply according to how frequently its author publishes.
I recognize that a manuscript can be long and still be poor quality. Length alone does not establish value, just as brevity alone does not establish its absence.
Nevertheless, when a publisher characterizes a work as low-content, the decision should be supported by an identifiable deficiency in the work itself.
I therefore ask Draft2Digital to distinguish between any specific concerns about the substance of my manuscripts and a generalized concern about the number or frequency of my publications.
5. The Use of Artificial Intelligence Must Be Distinguished From Automated Mass Production
Your notification refers to books created using automated means or mass-produced processes.
That wording raises an important question: what specific production process is being attributed to my titles, and what evidence supports that attribution?
There is a meaningful difference between using an AI tool to brainstorm, organize an outline, improve wording, check grammar, or explore alternative explanations and publishing unreviewed machine-generated material at scale.
A responsible publishing policy can distinguish between AI assistance, substantial human editorial involvement, and works generated entirely by automated systems without extensive human editing.
Draft2Digital's own published guidance states that AI-assisted content is supported, while content generated entirely by AI or large language models without extensive human editing is not accepted.
The distinction matters because the use of an AI tool does not, by itself, establish that a book is mass-produced or lacks substance. The relevant questions concern the actual manuscript, the production process, the extent of human involvement, and the applicable policy.
If Draft2Digital believes a particular title violates its AI-related requirements, I request a title-specific explanation of the alleged violation and an opportunity to provide relevant information about the manuscript's development and editing.
I am not asking Draft2Digital to abandon its standards. I am asking that those standards be applied with sufficient precision to distinguish legitimate authorship from the conduct the policy is intended to prevent.
6. Does Draft2Digital Have the Legal Right to Close an Account?
This is an important question, but it requires a distinction between what is contractually permitted and what is legally prohibited.
Draft2Digital's Terms of Service, effective April 14, 2026, state in Section 8 that the agreement may be terminated by either party, and that Draft2Digital may terminate the agreement with or without cause by providing notice. The terms also reserve the right to refuse account reactivation or the establishment of a new account.
The same terms recognize that authors retain ownership of their works, subject to the agreement and the rights necessary to provide the distribution service.
These provisions make it difficult to argue that account closure is automatically illegal merely because an author disagrees with the decision.
A business generally has considerable discretion to determine which works it will distribute, subject to its contractual obligations and applicable law.
However, contractual discretion is not necessarily unlimited in every respect. The circumstances surrounding a decision may matter, including whether the company complied with the agreement, made materially misleading representations, violated a specific legal obligation, or improperly withheld money that was contractually owed.
The relevant legal questions could include:
Contractual compliance: Did Draft2Digital follow the termination and payment provisions applicable to the account?
Royalty accounting: Have all royalties earned on eligible sales been accurately calculated and paid according to the agreement?
Accuracy of the stated grounds: Does the evidence support the specific characterization of the manuscripts, or was a material factual error made?
Applicable consumer or business laws: Does any particular state or federal law apply to the conduct in question?
Other contractual commitments: Were any separate written promises, agreements, or representations made that affect the analysis?
Without reviewing the complete account history, the relevant correspondence, the applicable version of the agreement, and the actual manuscripts, it would be premature to conclude that Draft2Digital acted illegally.
Equally, it would be premature to conclude that every aspect of the decision was legally unassailable simply because the company has a termination clause.
The existence of contractual discretion does not eliminate the importance of accurate facts, proper accounting, and compliance with applicable law.
I therefore reserve the right to seek independent legal advice if the evidence indicates that any contractual or legal obligation has not been met.
7. The Difference Between a Discretionary Decision and a Justified Decision
Draft2Digital states that it has determined, at its discretion, that the affected publications fall within prohibited categories.
Discretion may allow a company to make decisions without seeking an author's agreement. It does not make the reasoning behind those decisions immune from questions.
There is a difference between saying, "We have the right to discontinue this relationship," and demonstrating that the stated reasons accurately describe the work in question.
A company can possess the contractual authority to terminate an account while still making a factual error in explaining why it did so.
That distinction is important because a broad classification can have consequences beyond a single distribution relationship. It can affect the availability of an author's books, the continuity of distribution, and the author's ability to understand what must change to meet a platform's requirements.
A meaningful review should therefore identify the specific policy applied, the titles affected, the relevant deficiencies, and whether any correction or appeal process is available.
If the decision is based on a non-negotiable business policy, Draft2Digital can state that directly. If it is based on the substantive characteristics of particular books, those characteristics should be explained as precisely as reasonably possible.
A general notice that combines low-content, mass production, automation, and insufficient value does not, by itself, explain which allegation applies to each title.
8. A Request for Reconsideration and Specific Findings
In light of these concerns, I request the following:
First, provide the list of titles that were reviewed and the specific policy provisions applied to each relevant title.
Second, identify any passages, structural similarities, or other manuscript characteristics that support a finding of duplicated or mass-produced content.
Third, clarify whether the decision was based on actual manuscript deficiencies, the production process, publication frequency, sales performance, or a combination of factors.
Fourth, explain whether human editorial involvement, documentation of the writing process, or submission of revised manuscripts could have affected the outcome.
Fifth, confirm the status of outstanding royalties, provide the relevant sales accounting, and explain the expected payment timetable for amounts that remain payable under the agreement.
Sixth, confirm whether any internal reconsideration procedure is available, even if reinstatement is not guaranteed.
I understand that Draft2Digital may decline to reinstate the account. Nevertheless, a clear explanation would allow the decision to be assessed on its actual grounds rather than on assumptions about publishing productivity or commercial success.
Conclusion: Protect Publishing Standards Without Confusing Them With Commercial Performance
Publishing platforms have legitimate reasons to prevent deceptive listings, repetitive products, poorly prepared manuscripts, and content that does not meet their distribution standards.
Authors also have legitimate interests in having their work assessed accurately, receiving the royalties contractually owed to them, and understanding the basis for decisions that remove their publications from distribution.
These interests are not mutually exclusive.
A sustainable publishing ecosystem should be capable of distinguishing an empty notebook from a substantive nonfiction work, an unedited automated product from a carefully reviewed manuscript, and duplicated content from a collection of distinct original ideas.
It should also recognize that commercial success is not entirely within an author's control. Sales depend on discoverability, audience, competition, distribution, marketing, and financial resources. No author can guarantee that a book will sell enough copies to satisfy an arbitrary commercial expectation, and limited sales do not independently prove that a manuscript is deficient.
My position is therefore not that Draft2Digital must distribute every book submitted to it. My position is that the reasons given for rejecting an author's work should accurately reflect the actual basis for the decision, and that contractual rights should be exercised consistently with applicable obligations.
If particular titles fail to meet clearly defined content standards, identify those titles and explain the deficiencies. If the decision reflects a broader business policy, state that policy clearly. If money remains payable, ensure that the applicable accounting and payment obligations are fulfilled.
A publishing platform has the right to establish standards. An author has the right to ask what those standards mean in practice, how they were applied, and whether the resulting decision is consistent with the governing agreement.
I respectfully request a specific, evidence-based reconsideration of this matter.
The number of books an author publishes does not, by itself, establish the quality of those books. The number of copies sold does not establish their originality. And the absence of a substantial advertising budget does not transform substantive writing into low-content publishing.
The appropriate standard is the work itself, evaluated according to clearly articulated and consistently applied requirements.
Sincerely,
Leonardo Mora



Comments